Cataffo`s Pizza Welcome to Cataffo’s Pizza. A favorite on Long Island, we are located near the Stony Brook University campus and Stony Brook village . Best known for our specialty pizzas, we also have a full selection of calzones, salads and pasta dishes, all made with fresh ingredients every day. Our Buffalo Chicken Pizza, made with spicy chicken is a local favorite. The Cataffo’s Special has got the works, salami, pepperoni, ham, provolone, lettuce, tomatoes, onions, vinegar, oregano, oil, salt and pepper. What more could you ask for in a homemade-style pizza? Garlic knots, antipasto salads and stuffed calzones are just some of the reasons our customers love us. And we love them too. People have known to drive back from Queens, just for our food! Delivery and catering are available. Order online. Order Online